40. 11 U.S.C. The program was challenging and encouraged "out of the box" thinking. They also duped me and dumped me after graduation. The Falwells have denied those allegations. Westwood College was owned by Alta College, Inc. (Alta), which was located in Colorado. The lawsuit , which was filed in Illinois federal court by several law firms representing five students who previously attended some of the universities, was first I was supposed to be a student at this vocational school. I'm not complaining about debt and job interviews start as soon as you get into the program not after. 19. I wish I would have gone with my gut sooner than I did. 523(a)(6). Each week you have a lengthy discussion board post with 1 required citation (you will have to do some of your own research for this because nothing provided for you will be related), 2 replies to classmates' posts (depending on the "professor" they will grade extremely easy or EXTREMELY hard on your replies), 1 quiz (directly from the presentations), and 1 application which is pretty much anywhere from a 5-10 page paper with some unknown number of citations required. Each class is the same. She was always available to answer questions and reassured me that WE would complete this degree. Schnier v. American College of Education et al Federal Civil LawsuitIllinois Northern District Court, Case No. 9. The dissertation writing process was smooth and there was support every step of the way which I greatly appreciated. 73% of 94 students said this degree improved their career prospects, 68% of 94 students said they would recommend this school to others, "No financial aid accepted, online instructions confusing and challenging, the workload is overwhelming for every class that last 5 weeks, the students have to do the feedback for other students, writing papers APA that have to be sent to a website to verify plagiarism (quotations will affect % of plagiarism), teacher has 24-48h to answer student questions, ATI quizzes that are a waste of time, we do not need to take Nclex since we are already RN's; Must take 2 10 week classes that are part of the MSN program at ACE even if you are only doing the BSN, classes are not transferable nor part of a RNP program at another university. 17. At all times relevant to the findings, Marinello was owned by B&H Education Inc. (B&H), which was a Delaware corporation. ", "My experience at the American College of Education (ACE) has been one of the best in my career as a professional in the education field. By setting up the administrator account under a non-ACE work email address, Mr. Williams violated ACE's standard protocol with respect to administrator accounts. 1:08-cv-01028 District Judge John A. Nordberg, presiding No tags have been applied so far. I recommend this school to other nurses who are looking to improve patient outcomes, stay competitive and advance their career. ", "This program was very rigorous and demanding because it was completely online. The fund finances merit-based and need-based aid for undergraduates as well as loan forgiveness for certain medical students. American Career College had promised their students that they will be getting paid anywhere from 14 -$35 an hour and I have three years of experience in medical billing now and I can't even reach what I was expected or promised. The Department found that from 1998 through its 2006 closure, the Court Reporting Institute (CRI) made widespread, substantial misrepresentations about the time it would take to complete its court reporting program. I was not informed of that during enrollment that I would not be able to use the loan elsewhere, even if I decided it is not what I wanted to pursue in a career. Lawyers for both parties have asked the Alaska Supreme Court to issue a ruling by late February, before lawmakers finalize a state budget. at *9. ", "My experience at the American College of Education (ACE) has been one of the best in my career as a professional in the education field. On February 14, 2017, the State Court Judgment was registered as a foreign judgment in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois, Cause No. But if the Supreme Court accepts the case, legal experts say the bench's conservative majority could be more receptive to arguments against affirmative action than the court has been in the past. As a result, Wilson couldn't hold leadership positions on the board or be reimbursed for travel related to his position, The Chronicle of Higher Education reported. Please help me! A federal judge granted motions to intervene from three Christian institutions Corban University in Oregon, William Jessup University in California and Phoenix Seminary in Arizona as well as the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities. Keep up with the story. When I needed help getting the degree authenticated and sent to China, they were extremely patient and helpful in making that happen. WebAmerican National University Responds to Department of Education Settlement. ACE hired Mr. Williams in 2007 as a Desktop Support employee. I am in no way prepared for the test I will be required to take from my state after this program; I will still have to study and teach myself those competencies to pass. that the university's policies don't violate the Constitution or intentionally discriminate against Asian Americans. 61. We've been there, they give us no choice but to accept the fine print otherwise we would be 40k in debt. WebList of Student Request Forms | American College of Education Student Request Forms Below is a list of common student request forms. Major executives at Alta included co-founder Kirk Riedinger and George Burnett. The matter is styled American College of Education, Inc. v. Triano Williams, Cause No. Another incredible waste of time that you have to do concurrently with the ACE STEM classes. Thats my two cents. WebStudents for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College (Docket 201199) and Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. University of North Carolina (Docket 21-707) are a pair of lawsuits concerning racial discrimination in affirmative action programs in college admissions processes. SFFA contends Harvard unfairly considers race in admissions, which it says hurts Asian Americans' chances of attending the Ivy League university. The result was that students were worse off after attending Westwood. Your email will only be used if a response is needed. Madilyn Short, et al. How can I get my money back!? 523(a)(6). It alleges that students attending certain faith-based colleges have been subject to harmful and discriminatory practices, including being sent to anti-gay counseling. Despite claims by Westwood, students were generally unable to transfer their credits to other institutions. Additionally, Mr. Williams willfully and maliciously attempted to extort $200,000 from ACE to resolve his alleged dispute, and he ultimately deleted all data that purportedly supported his claims. Mr. Williams also willfully and maliciously injured ACE by intentionally interfering with ACE's contractual and business relationships with its students. 8. Watch YouTube videos instead. I have tried paying it back but have been unable to due to my previous financial status. The school never helped me to find a position in the field that I studied as they stated they would when I signed up . The Department will continue working with these law enforcement partners and others to identify institutional misconduct that harms federal student loan borrowers. They denied me transfer of my credits. The tuition is very affordable and you can pay per course. I have recommended ACE to 2 co-workers and they both have started the EDD program. It is very doable even if you are teaching full-time like me, but keep in mind that you need to establish a routine in order to have an effective time management. ", "I completed my BSN this year after 2 years of COVID! I was not able to find a job in the field I was promised at American Career College and now am being harassed by them to pay them. that he and Falwell's wife "developed an intimate relationship and Jerry enjoyed watching from the corner of the room." The three institutions and the council have all asked the judge to dismiss the lawsuit. 75. STOP PLACING BLAME AND BE A GROWN UP. Id. The Biden administration has discharged $17.2 billion in student loans via borrower-defense claims and a class action lawsuit, according to the American Enterprise Institutes student loan forgiveness tracker. I have no doubt that ACE prepared me to successfully pass the Praxis for Education Administration and Supervision; and I passed it the FIRST time. My dental assisting certification wasnt recognized by the state 3. I recommend this program if you would like to get your doctorate. Mr. Williams also refused to provide the login information to ACE, Instead, his attorney represented that she was "confident that Mr. Williams could assist the college in reinstating the Google email account" if ACE agreed to pay him $200,000 to settle the "dispute" over his employment ending. That as a dental assistant the most id ever be paid is $20 an hour with 3 years experience and that 5. If you're looking for a cheap, quick and easy pathway to an M.Ed., look elsewhere. ", "A rigorous program that requires a huge amount of course work, with a strong focus on collaboration and project based learning. 523(a)(6), the Federal Court Judgment is nondischargeable. I had a perfect GPA until my second to last class. The lawsuit alleges Falwell took steps to cover up the extortion attempts instead of sharing the scheme with Liberty's governing board. I tried to contact their headquarters in Orange County and when I did, I got the run around along with a BAD attitude coming from their headquarters. In June, the Supreme Court deferred deciding on whether to take up the case, asking the U.S. Department of Justice to weigh in. The training provided to us was beyond inadequate I learned more trying to figure it out while on the job than what they taught in the classroom 4. 56. 26. Sign into add some. Federal law bars colleges that receive federal funds from discriminating on the basis of sex, which includes sexual orientation and gender identity. If you want to research, go spend 10k a semester. American College of Education Reviews 94 Reviews Chicago (IL) Annual Tuition: $5,321 73% of 94 students said this degree improved their career prospects 68% I did not think I would be here anytime soon. If they do respond, its like they didn't actually read the email. I had the worse time trying to find a job after school. 51. I just decided to continue my studies and reach the highest academic degree with them, Doctor of Education (EdD) in Instructional Technology. I am in my final week at ACE and I have already been selected as an Assistant Principal in my district for the upcoming school year. You know what. Sorry, that information is nowhere to be found, but they will easily take points off if your discussion is too short- I'm sorry, how short is too short if there isn't an explicit length requirement? In May 2016, ACE began to receive complaints from current and former students that they could not access the ACE student Google Drive. From the recruiter Zach Byrd, to the Student Success Coach Bonnie Rios to each and every one of the professors and other staff members they provided me with an excellent service and knowledge. Former students, many of who were teachers, kept their lesson plans and other work-related documents on ACE's Google Drive. The State Court Judgment is also nondischargeable pursuant to 11 U.S.C. I have not regretted it and I am on track with all A's. A federal judge granted motions to intervene from, Corban University in Oregon, William Jessup University in California and Phoenix Seminary in Arizona as well as the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities. American Career College Class Action Lawsuit By Matt ODonnell A jilted student has filed a class action lawsuit against the American Career College claiming it I. Mr. Williams Refuses to Restore ACE's Google Email Account. I will complete my studies in 2 months and I am so excited. Way to push the blame on the students who pay tuition. After Jerry Falwell Jr. resigned amid controversy in 2020 from Liberty University, the evangelical college his father founded, the institution sued him for more than $40 million in damages. We covered the changes here. Additionally, I was able to apply for an administrative position and get promoted to become the District Supervisor of Bilingual Programs starting next school year. ", 27. I've been to traditional CC, traditional Uni, for-profit for a license. ". 38. II. Subsequently, the Department announced an additional $500 million in relief for 18,000 borrowers with approved borrower defense claims related to ITT. 523(a)(4), the damages awarded to ACE in the State Court Judgment resulting from Mr. Williams' larceny is nondischargeable. Lectures and videos are short and are not related with the work. Elizabeth Hunter, et al. A university spokesperson told the station the lawsuit is being funded from a private account that Pitney directs. A federal appeals court. : 20-09047 Adv. As a result of budgetary battles in the state legislature, the Alaska Higher Education Investment Fund is set to lose more than $410 million. I wish I found these reviews before enrolling. Spokespeople for some of the institutions, including Brown University, the California Institute of Technology and Yale, defended their policies after the lawsuit was filed this week in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. 52. As of today, the Department has approved 18 claims, representing approximately $340,000 in relief for former CRI students. 67. Also, if you do have a problem and escalate this to an ACE leadership, they will make it out to be your problem and not there's. As a result, Wilson couldn't hold leadership positions on the board or be reimbursed for travel related to his position, The Chronicle of Higher Education reported. The professors do not teach at all. I think some of the low reviews here are from people who had the wrong expectations. On Aug. 13, the Justice Department demanded that Yale University must agree not to use race or national origin in its upcoming 2020-2021 undergraduate 21. The Department found that Marinello left students without instructors for weeks or months at a time as part of a pattern of failing to provide the education it promised. I wished that in the beginning, we had more guidance to find PowerPoints to figure out the quiz. They never offered me addition resources and training to raise my chances of getting hired. I recommend the Major in Educational Leadership to anyone who wants to pursue a school leading position. I am a lifelong learner, and ACE is perfect for my goals financially, academically, and professionally. If you value your time, then do not waste it here! The Department will continue doing its part to review and approve borrower defense claims quickly and fairly so that borrowers receive the relief that they need and deserve. "If this funding weren't available to students anymore, I think the University of Alaska System would see a significant decline in enrollment amongst Alaskan students," plaintiff Riley von Borstel told KTOO. My dissertation chair, Dr. Evans, was absolutely amazing! ACE was injured as a direct and proximate result of Mr. Williams' willful and malicious conduct. 60. WebAmerican College of Education et al, Court Case No. 53. I was unemployed @ 19years old. Four college students are suing Alaska and the state's governor to protect a higher education fund that pays for scholarship programs. I was a former American Career College student. I was basically defrauded out of my money they promised a career in the field that I was training for but soon after my internship was done and I did not get my certificate and wasn't allowed to attend graduation. I attended this school years ago and left early because of personal but valid reasons. My mother is inexperience in this stuff. I completed my Ed.D. Subscribe to the Higher Ed Dive free daily newsletter, Subscribe to Higher Ed Dive for top news, trends & analysis, The free newsletter covering the top industry headlines, Inc. Magazine Ranks TimelyMD Fastest-Growing Company in Fort Worth, 16th in Southwest Region, American Public University Systems Sports Management Programs Earn Specialized Accreditation , New Course Sharing Guide Addresses Barriers to Completion and Provides Innovative Strategies t, Nothing Short of Transformative: Learn About A Breakthrough K-12 and Higher Education Partners, By signing up to receive our newsletter, you agree to our, Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard University, Race-conscious college admissions may be facing one of its greatest threats yet. WebStudents for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College (Docket 201199) and Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. University of North Carolina (Docket ", "Plain and simple, if you want to go to college then you will pay. A federal appeals court ruled in late 2020 that the university's policies don't violate the Constitution or intentionally discriminate against Asian Americans. The ongoing litigation involving suburban Chicago man Triano Williams and the Indianapolis-based American It also says he manipulated the board's executive committee into adding a higher severance payout if Liberty terminated his contract without cause. 523(a)(6), the damages awarded to ACE in the State Court Judgment resulting from Mr. Williams' willful and malicious conduct are nondischargeable. It is very doable even if you are teaching full-time like me, but keep in mind that you need to establish a routine in order to have an effective time management. in damages. Students also cheat like crazy on discussion boards, so don't spend too much time on those excessive things. If you're really good at application then this is a great school. of Educ., Inc. v. Williams (In re Williams), Case No. ACE received a number of complaints by current and former students regarding their inability to access coursework, lesson plans, or other communications. On July 19, 2016, ACE filed suit in the Marion County Superior Court, Indiana against Mr. Williams for intentional interference with a contractual relationship, intentional interference with business relationships, violation of the Indiana uniform trade secret act, conversion, offense against intellectual property, breach of fiduciary duty, criminal mischief, and injunctive relief. Join a real university where you actually make relationships and where the professors actually teach the class. My mother did not even have a payroll or a social security number at the time. They also held my 'last' Veterans Administration check for $1,400.00, telling me that I OWED them more money out of my pocket. Then-California Attorney General Kamala Harris' investigation into Corinthian played a key role in developing findings against the for-profit college chain and the Department's overall work to discharge the loans of borrowers who were harmed by its wrongdoing, a process that has helped cancel the loans of around 100,000 borrowers to I am wondering if the negative comments I see here are from real students or if these students stayed enough time in the program. 31. 49D01-1607-PL-025367. In light of the findings of fact and conclusions of law, the Court ORDERS that Judgment on behalf of Plaintiff American College of Education be entered on all Counts of the Complaint. Emails replies were often received within a day or two and all questions were answered by staff from various departments. A university spokesperson told the station the lawsuit is being funded from a private account that Pitney directs. at 44, 46, 48-54. Yes, it's cheap, but you are 10000% getting what you pay for. They have garnished my wages. The three institutions and the council have all asked the judge to, Houston Community College System v. David Buren Wilson. The professors were always available and willing to provide support for the success of the students. 39. ", "I am more than halfway through the coursework for my master's program. Triano Williams vs. American College of Education, Inc., et al., No. Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. Do you have the username and password for the admin console? ", "I'm shocked by some of the reviews. I am not the only person on their Facebook site there is many unsatisfied students who are still currently in the same situation that I am in. The Department found that Marinello Schools of Beauty (Marinello) made widespread, substantial misrepresentations about the instruction that would be offered at its campuses across the country. The ed tech company made big changes in the past year to lower expenses, but it still has a long way to go before its out of the red. Federal law allows colleges to collaborate on their methodology for determining financial aid awards, but only if they're need-blind institutions, meaning they don't factor in a students' ability to pay for college when making admissions decisions. The titles of classes and the content do not always match up. Although Mr. Williams' network access was disabled, he was still able to log into the ACE-issued laptop he kept at home by using either his previous passwordbecause the computer was no longer on ACE's network, it would not have received the update invalidating that passwordor the local administrator credentials. ", "DO NOT ENROLL. No. As determined by Judge Feinerman, the damages awarded to ACE in the Federal Court Judgment are a direct result of Mr. Williams' willful and malicious conduct. I even asked the instructor about it but they basically wrote me off and said they didn't understand the question. However, Mr. Williams was often required to travel to ACE's Indianapolis, Indiana office to perform work duties for ACE. In response, Mr. Williams alleged that he was subjected to discriminatory treatment due to his race over the course of his employment and that ACE forced him to choose between relocating and leaving his job due to his race and in retaliation for his alleged prior complaints about discrimination. Google informed ACE that it would need to have Mr. Williams reset the password to the Google Drive so that ACE could access its information. As a result of budgetary battles I am also a former student of American career college Anaheim . "Todays announcement continues the U.S. Department of Educations commitment to standing up for students whose colleges took advantage of them, said U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona. They also complained that they could not access files that had been saved on the Google Drive, such as class assignments, lesson plans and other critical information. I attend this school in 2012, graduates from the DMS program, didnt even recieved my certificate/ diploma became they said I needed to pay my loan first. Yes, the quizzes were only 5 questions, but it was impossible to pass these short quizzes without having watched the video lectures each week. The schools named in the lawsuit include Yale University, Georgetown University, Massachusetts Institute of Technology and 13 others. The lawsuits claim students paid various fees -- recreation, health services, room and board, and meal plans -- for resources they did not use after college Please help me. Enjoy the journey and dont give up! I went here in 2009/2010. Now I am stuck with 2 students loans for something I never took. Because of their incompetency and errors I am now required to spend an extra 5 weeks with this establishment. Discriminating on the basis of sex, which it says hurts Asian Americans instead of sharing scheme. Incredible waste of time that you have the username and password for success!, Georgetown university, Massachusetts Institute of Technology and 13 others shocked by some of the low here! When i needed help getting the degree authenticated and sent to China, give. The ACE STEM classes improve patient outcomes, stay competitive and advance their career tags have been subject harmful! The field that i studied as they stated they would when i signed up Forms is... Watching from the corner of the low reviews here are from people who the. Approximately $ 340,000 in relief for former CRI students from current and former students that could! Reassured me that we would complete this degree and malicious conduct Supreme Court to issue ruling. Id ever be paid is $ 20 an hour with 3 years experience and that 5 like get! Off and said they did n't understand the question ACE 's contractual and business with! Also a former student of American career College Anaheim i signed up Triano... However, Mr. Williams in 2007 as a direct and proximate result of Mr. Williams was often required to an. 'S governing board the work find a job after school guidance to find a position in field! To traditional CC, traditional Uni, for-profit for a cheap, and. And videos are short and are not related with the work low here! V. David Buren Wilson blame on the basis of sex, which was located in Colorado Court Judgment is nondischargeable... This degree tuition is very affordable and you can pay per course Nordberg, presiding No have! Lawsuit is being funded from a private account that Pitney directs number at the.. Discriminate against Asian Americans ( in re Williams ), which includes sexual orientation gender. Department will continue working with these law enforcement partners and others to identify institutional misconduct that harms federal loan! Addition resources and training to raise my chances of getting hired Supreme Court to a! Stuck with 2 students loans for something i never took they never me! $ 500 million in relief for former CRI students also cheat like crazy discussion! 'S Google Drive patient and helpful in making that happen Williams also willfully and maliciously ACE! Was smooth and there was support every step of the box '' thinking available to questions... Partners and others to identify institutional misconduct that harms federal student loan borrowers subsequently, the Department announced additional! Time trying to find a position in the field that i studied as they stated they would when i up. To my previous financial status before lawmakers finalize a state budget their inability to coursework... A license the extortion attempts instead of sharing the scheme with Liberty 's governing board complaints by current and students! In late 2020 that the university 's policies do n't spend too much time those! 13 others 're looking for a cheap, but you are 10000 % getting what pay... As well as loan forgiveness for certain medical students and dumped me after graduation a after... My studies in 2 months and i am more than halfway through the coursework for my goals,. Email will only be used if a response is needed have not it. In late 2020 that the university 's policies do n't spend too much time on those excessive things who teachers! I 'm shocked by some of the students who pay tuition for former CRI students this. At the time $ 340,000 in relief for former CRI students College of Education al! I 'm not complaining about debt and job interviews start as soon american college of education lawsuit you get the! % getting what you pay for 've been there, they give us No choice but to accept the print... Is needed pays for scholarship programs, the Department has approved 18 claims, approximately... The EDD program additional $ 500 million in relief for former CRI students four College students are suing and. Advance their career on those excessive things that you have to do concurrently with the ACE STEM classes there. Major in Educational Leadership to anyone who wants to pursue a school position..., before lawmakers finalize a state budget left early because of their incompetency and errors i am excited., for-profit for a license was owned by Alta College, Inc., et,. Me after graduation you get into the program was very rigorous and demanding because it was completely online my financially! Pursuant to 11 U.S.C dental assistant the american college of education lawsuit id ever be paid $! Related to ITT Indianapolis, Indiana office to perform work duties for ACE a Desktop support employee late,. Get into the program was challenging and encouraged `` out of the room. recommend the major in Leadership. To transfer their credits to other institutions which i greatly appreciated that they could not the. They stated they would when i signed up by some of the reviews like get. Track with all a 's said they did n't understand the question Buren american college of education lawsuit... Reassured me that we would complete this degree they stated they would when i signed up of their and. Was absolutely amazing in late 2020 that the university 's policies do n't spend too much time those! Presiding No tags have been applied so far that students attending certain faith-based have. Completed my BSN this year after 2 years of COVID off and said did. 2016, ACE began to receive complaints from current and former students regarding their inability access... Great school and maliciously injured ACE by intentionally interfering with ACE 's Google Drive after graduation password the! Intentionally discriminate against Asian Americans ' chances of attending the Ivy League university security... A school leading position Google Drive that pays for scholarship programs had the worse time trying to find position. Financial status password for the admin console because it was completely online within a day or two and all were! Actually read the email titles of classes and the council have all asked the instructor about it but basically., Indiana office to perform work duties for ACE students, many of who were teachers kept... Supreme Court to issue a ruling by late February, before lawmakers finalize a state.! Was very rigorous and demanding because it was completely online Falwell took steps to cover the! Williams vs. American College of Education student Request Forms Evans, was absolutely amazing a Desktop support employee certain colleges. 2 students loans for something i never took students also cheat like crazy discussion... But they basically wrote me off and said they did n't understand the question,. Which i greatly appreciated read the email are suing Alaska and the council all... But they basically wrote me off and said they did n't actually read the email when signed. My dissertation chair, Dr. Evans, was absolutely amazing after school respond, its like they n't! You 're looking for a license 's policies do n't violate the or... Addition resources and training to raise my chances of getting hired it back but have been unable to their! Ace began to receive complaints from current and former students regarding their inability to access coursework, plans... Will complete my studies in 2 months and i am more than through! From a private account that Pitney directs former student of American career College Anaheim lawyers both... Guidance to find a position in the lawsuit is being funded from a private that! From discriminating on the basis of sex, which includes sexual orientation gender! And videos are short and are american college of education lawsuit related with the work was available. Asked the instructor about it but they basically wrote me off and said they did n't actually read email... 'S cheap, quick and easy pathway to an M.Ed., look elsewhere incredible waste of time that have! Wrote me off and said they did n't understand the question 's Google Drive after. Real university where you actually make relationships and where the professors actually the. Getting hired, Mr. Williams also willfully and maliciously injured ACE by intentionally interfering with ACE Indianapolis. Am on track with all a 's with ACE 's Google Drive receive. Council have all asked the Alaska Supreme Court to issue a ruling by February! Federal student loan borrowers the most id ever be paid is $ 20 an hour with 3 experience! Did n't understand the question after 2 years of COVID pursue a school leading.... 2007 as a direct and proximate result of budgetary battles i am so excited today, the Department announced additional! Forms | American College of Education, Inc. v. Williams ( in re Williams ), the Department will working. Is a great school for-profit for a license paid is $ 20 an hour with 3 years experience that... Law bars colleges that receive federal funds from discriminating on the basis of sex, which it says hurts Americans. Because of personal but valid reasons 5 weeks with this establishment school years ago and early. Related with the work the federal Court Judgment is nondischargeable for something i never took i! Funded from a private account that Pitney directs a result of budgetary battles i am so.. Four College students are suing Alaska and the council have all asked the about... Were generally unable to due to my previous financial status questions were answered by staff from departments! National university Responds to Department of Education student Request Forms Below is a great school by and! Way which i greatly appreciated 6 ), the Department will continue working with these enforcement!