The whipped cream, which is more of a whipped topping, almost hits its mark but its not quite as creamy as wed like it to be, leaning more on the sugary-air side. By. We anticipate getting some blowback by putting the Five Guys grilled cheese in the last place. Toppings. Others thought the lighter chocolate taste was great. It makes for a bite that is more "hot dog and cheese sandwich" than traditional cheese dog and, in theory, we're fans of that. The diverse creation is piled with freshly grilled onions, mushrooms, green peppers, lettuce, and tomatoes, and we added pickles for a bit of an acidic zing. Like the McFlurry, the milkshakes utilize McDonalds signature vanilla ice cream as its base, but its cut and blended with either McCafe vanilla, strawberry, or chocolate syrup, which slightly warms the ice cream and changes the consistency in order to make it drinkable. I want to walk away from a milkshake thinking that was a good milkshake not that milkshake was thick! People who care about thickness over flavor are shallow milkshake drinkers. Its just way too sweet. The milkshakes and fries were tasty but not worth the money and the drinks machines were surprisingly tricky to use. Well send you our daily roundup of all our favorite stories from across the site, from travel to food to shopping to entertainment. This can be as simple as chocolate ice cream blended with chocolate syrup, or something much more chocolaty. Which is great if you mainline coffee all day, every day. You do you. Cookies and cream milkshakes are so popular, and people usually, people opt for Oreo milkshakes. I just got my second vaccine shot. The next closest is nearly two hours away and I like milkshakes (and my job), but not that much. Whatever. Peanut butter cookies are truly tasty, too. All of Five Guys' milkshakes start with a base of vanilla ice cream, . "If you can give a good haircut or if you can serve a good drink at a bar or if you can serve a good hamburger, you can always make money in America." Milkshakes. The rules were simple: hand-formed, fresh-ground beef; fries cooked in peanut oil; no freezers. Instant coffee is passable, too. Salted Caramel is always a great and easy choice, but feel free to get weird here. For example, check out that less-than-crispy slice of bacon that made it atop our burger. Im a little torn on this milkshake. Through thick and thin, scooped with a spoon or sipped through a straw, chocolate milkshakes are a delicious treat. "Easily the most decadent and highest quality of chocolate of them all," one editor wrote. If anything, this monstrous meaty gem is evidence that there is nothing better than doing the basics well except, of course, when you do all of the basics well and then combine them. One editor stated the shake was "extremely milky, less chocolatey." And with nearly four times the amount of restaurants as their next biggest rival, they've got an impressive head start. A post shared by Steak 'n Shake (@steaknshake). But this milkshake flavor is pretty widespread and indeed has bits of Oreo cookie sprinkled throughout, which sets it above plainer milkshakes on the menu. The shake itself is sweet, but nothing remarkable, and the sludge-y not quite thick not quite watery consistency really doesnt do it any favors. For more flavor, add peanut butter or chocolate sauce, or top with whipped cream. To construct these amazing fries, Five Guys starts with their regular, boardwalk-style method. The only problem with this otherwise-epic masterpiece is an issue similar to the one we experienced with the veggie sandwich: there's a lot of meat, here, and not a lot of moisture to hold it all together. Or usea different base ice cream (such as mint or strawberry). Verdict: The best thing about these shakes from Five Guys are all the different mix-ins you can add alongside the hand spun vanilla. The grilled onions in the mix makes the entire thing a gooey, griddled delight. Murrell took the advice to heart, and also carried it on to the next generation. At first glance, it's merely tan-colored, with small specks of peanut butter barely visible. Im not a fan of doubling up the meat on burgers (Id rather just eat two burgers, and vary the condiments), so I like a single patty, but there is some sort of alchemy to mixing barbecue sauce and mayonnaise, and when you combine that with the acid from the pickles and the heat from the fresh jalapeos, its a pretty damn glorious burger. Creamy, sweet, decadent milkshakes. } else { we strive to provide the best experience each and every time you visit. Add butterscotch candiesor toffee bits. You dont really have options here, chocolate is better than vanilla, but if you love vanilla, go for it. The cheese and bacon hot dog was a lesson in too much of a good thing, as the saltiness of the hot dog, the saltiness of the bacon, and the saltiness of the American cheese made me long to pour pickle jar vinegar or really any type of acid directly into my mouth. Its just too much vanilla. Cheers to that! The experience is entirely better than dipping your fries in a milkshake, providing a crispy crunch that makes the mouth feel of the shake a delicious savory part of the experience. But after spending the last few years eating 330 burgers from independent restaurants all over the country, I hadnt been back to Five Guys. Most people add a tablespoon or so of peanut butter to the blend to get the flavor they love. One editor wrote that "you can see the chocolate sauce in it," which made it a "very rich, decadent-tasting treat." The flavor and texture, however, were what we judged. 10. Then go with this: a patty melt; (don't forget the grilled onion); a regular hot dog with relish, mustard, and raw onion; Cajun fries; and a Banana Bacon Chocolate milkshake. Like the famousmalted milkshake, the butterscotch milkshake was hugely popular years ago and has now become acult classic. Nutrition and Allergen Information; HOW FIVE GUYS IS MADE. Banana . Right on the heels of winning our French fry taste test, Shake Shack made its way to the top of our chocolate milkshake taste test. But they lose points on the price. Five Guys' peanut butter milkshake has a vanilla base (as all of their shakes do), blended with natural, creamy peanut butter. Michael Strange says it's because"the flavors work really well together"and "this combination has been around for years, and many people think of this as the 'classic'milkshake, evoking childhood memories." Care a little about your sugar intake? Thats an insult to chocolate milkshakes. The sandwich has a legitimate cult following amongst Five Guys fans. Youre going to wish you had a spoon to eat this one. Five Guys Burgers & Fries is the largest fast-casual burger chain by a longshot. But Ive decided to go with my second favorite, Neopolitan, to prove a larger point about In-N-Out milkshakes. Anyone got any other suggestions? There are other winners on the menu, too. Dogs. Now, of . They have a section dedicated to best sellers on their online menu as if to convince all of us that they actually sell food that people like. If you're not a huge chocolate lover and love whipped cream on your frozen treats, you'll love this chocolate milkshake! ", Overall, our editors appreciated the authentic taste of the shake. In fact, they're pretty delicious. People love this shake because its thick, which Id guess theyre mistaking for richness, but at the end of the day who cares if its thick? Double StufCookies and cream -- even of the Oreo variety -- has been done before. So today, I finally did it. This milkshake is pretty much a meal, so dont plan to eat anything else if you order it. Last one I probably had was a shamrock shake maybe 3 years ago. As with any combo, the attention to detail on any one aspect of this burger may suffer as a result of there being more going on overall. Who wouldve thought Sonic was this good at anything? BaconFive Guys went rogue and actually put real bits of bacon in the milkshake blender, though the results are just so-so. Shake Shack does have some delicious creamy high-quality custard to top their milkshakes though, well give them that. The patty melt benefits from the fact that they flip over a regular bun and double grill it with what would normally be the inside of the bun as the outside, and two layers of cheese encasing the burger patty. Also known as a "Black & White", this favorite is avanilla ice cream milkshake with chocolate syrup either blended in during the milkshake making or swirled in afterward. This shake is a chocolate lover's dream. With more than 250,000 ways to customize your burger and 1,000+ milkshake combinations, satisfying your craving is just a . Five Guys expanded nationally in 2003, and has since opened more than 1,500 locations, Five Guys keeps it simple with a menu of burgers, hot dogs, shakes, and fries, The off-menu patty melt is basically a grilled cheese with a burger inside it, Milkshakes are uniformly great, but the Elvis is King, Burgers are customizable, allowing you to choose your own adventure, eating 330 burgers from independent restaurants, BURN THE ICE: The American Culinary Revolution and Its End, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Or at least some fries. I wouldn't order it." Im not lactose intolerant, but I am human. Whether it's using fresh ground beef (there are no freezers in our restaurants), double-cooking our fries in 100 percent peanut oil, hand-preparing fresh ingredients every morning or serving peanuts while you wait, we strive to provide the . The idea of fast-food burger chains versus fast-casual is a scary topic for me. (Sorry not the best visual to lead into a food article with.). But that being said, we did find this option refreshing and (for reasons that are readily evident) more healthy tasting than the rest of the menu. Your favorite Daym Drops-approved burger joint is about to get even better. Still, others disagreed and said it had the "weakest chocolate flavortastes like there is just chocolate syrup mixed in" and that it was "too milky, not a fan. No berries? It is a menu item that people can get for less than $5, which makes it an affordable option for customers. They weren't kidding about the Double Stuf part -- you can taste the extra cream filling in this thick, cookie-blasted shake. If it wasnt a promotional item wed probably rank this one higher. For other mix-ins, try a good brandy,dried organic orange peels, gourmet berry jam or fresh, pitted cherries. Now, let's see how these five fast-food chocolate milkshakes stacked up against each other, ranked from worst to best. Five Guys provides a range of toppings as well, including banana, chocolate, Oreo Creme and more. At its core, it's a vanilla milkshake, just like all the milkshakes on the Five Guys menu are, with various add-ins. This milkshake is straight-up gourmet with a complex flavor that is creamy, then tangy, then sweet with hints of cherry and bright strawberry, and finishes with the slightly nutty earthy flavor of graham crackers. Most people add frozen bananas (which were peeled when very ripe and then frozen in a plastic bag or other sealed container) to keep the temperature down. Popular Five Guys Menu Items, Ranked Worst To Best. With more than 250,000 ways to customize your burger and more than 1,000 milkshake combinations, your perfect meal is just a click away! It was expensive. Don't have peanut butter? Another said she was "not a fan of the chunky texture. Salted CaramelIt takes a few sips for the caramel to really hit, but once you're in that sweet spot, this is one solid shake. This stuff tastes like sugared air. Simply make a vanilla milkshake, and swirl in some butterscotch sauce. single The lack of advertising, the lack of real trendy innovations on the menu, all of those things seem like very wise counterintuitive choices now. Back then, just the act of knowing about Five Guys was cool, and every little quirk (the peanut boxes, the standard order being two patties, etc) built the lore that has somehow sustained itself as the chain becomes a behemoth. I usually get vanilla (anyone who calls vanilla bland/boring can fight me) but if I'm looking for a combo, my go-to is either vanilla with Oreos or vanilla with bacon bits (sounds weird, but it's actually good). I recommend the latter, as it gives a much better flavor. The whipped cream is an absolute joke, skip it. It's not much to think about, either, as a peanut butter milkshake is fairly standard. Come along for the ride! Maybe we haven't sampled enough BLTs to know, but one bite into this bad boy and it was clear: Five Guys knows how good their bacon is, and is willing to run with that truth. I dont think there is a single fast-food restaurant that has more noticeable self-loathing in its own menu than Burger King. The clearest competitors to Five Guys are Shake Shack (around 200 total locations), Smashburger (370), Habit Burger (250), and Fat Burger (over 200). If you haven't ever tried a Five Guys fry, drop what you're doing immediately and go grab a bag. Five Guys' passion for food is shared with our fans, which is why we never compromise. I ate the entire thing AFTER I'd sampled two burgers, two hot dogs, two other sandwiches, two orders of fries, and two milkshakes. When the veggie sandwich was delivered, it was falling apart. Lets jump in! Go with the BLT. If Shake Shacks milkshakes had the consistency of the Frosty, it would be a winner, but unfortunately, its just an upper mid-tier milkshake that is only saved by its flavor. This is perhaps the only mainstream burger chain that's imaginative enough to dream up the easy yet groundbreaking concept of putting a cheeseburger's cheese betweenits patties. So drinking a double-digit number of them in an absurdly compact window of time could never be a bad thing right? But after tasting it, we couldn't help but wonder which higher power that cult is loyal to. How to Make A Five Guys Grilled Cheese. But bacon in a milkshake its not exactly what comes to mind when we want a milkshake, so for that reason, it cant get the top spot, as good as it is. For extra flavor, add in broken peanut butter cups or top with whipped cream and a little chocolate sauce. Good! If you're looking for something plain, the bacon meat edges out the burger. You can always opt for their classic fries and get the seasoning on the side. Macadamia nut milkshake =better yet. Skip the waxen chocolate pieces and artificial color found in most mint chocolate ice creams. We have now officially entered the "everything from this point on is worth trying" territory. No mint-chocolate ice cream? These popular milkshake flavors all have one thing in common:coffee. Its a nice flavor alternative to the other more standard milkshake flavors like chocolate or vanilla. My personal favorite is Black Sugar Vanilla, with its aromatic vanilla and complex notes of burnt butter and caramel. Be careful not to suck any chocolate chips down your throat without chewing, though. Its a great texture for a milkshake, and Steak n Shake takes it a step forward by crumbing Kit Kits into the whipped cream. Five Guys Onalaska: Cheeseburger, hot dog, fries, and milkshakes in Onalaska Our Onalaska location is slated to open in late March! The appearance was deceiving for some, but for others, it lined right up with their rating. For add-ins, try chocolate candies, brownie bits, chocolate cookies, chocolate cake or chocolate syrup/sauce. Keep an eye out for the milkshake menu at Five Guys locations in New York and New Jersey as they continue to expand, and pray to the fast-food gods that those peanut butter and Double Stuf shakes get permanent placement nationwide. But its still somehow smooth enough to drink through a straw, so its not really ice cream either so it is kind of a milkshake? Get the best food tips and diet advice One editor disliked the treat and said it "tasted artificial. For starters, it didn't transport as well as others. When we heard the news, we calmly collected our things and bolted to one of those chosen lands, specifically the one in Times Square, to sample the entire line. 6254a4d1642c605c54bf1cab17d50f1e, Shocked. "A horror show. Butterscotch milkshakes are easy to create. Five Guys is the refined grown-up version of dipping your fries in a Frosty. Lindsey Goodwin is a food writer and tea consultant with more than 12 years of experience exploring tea production and culture. Mocha. Almond butter milkshake =better. To find out, I spoke withMichael Strange, president of the ever-popularBassetts Ice Cream Company in Philadelphia, asked a few friends whose milkshakes bring all the boys (and girls) to the yardand checked with a few internet forums. This may feel familiar. . Get easy-to-follow, delicious recipes delivered right to your inbox. Even plain, the burger is an enjoyable if not entirely noteworthy experience. Any less, and these would taste like a slightly upgraded classic fry. But the real beauty of Five Guys is the fact that, actually, you don't have to choose. According to the menu, this makes for a "caramelized exterior." You wont find BKs shakes on that menu, and it looks like the King knows that no one could stomach a whole shake from them, which is why theyre only sold in mini-sizes. Unless you dont like Kit Kats, in which case you can get Butterfinger (weird) Peanut Butter Cup (acceptable), or even Nutella. If refreshing and bright isnt your thing, grab the Choco Hazelnut Chip. [Editor: BURGERVILLE!] On the other are those who are staunchly anti-fungus and want no such thing on their sandwich. "Dear reader, I'm embarrassed to tell you how much I liked this shake. Think less notes of Hershey's syrup and more semi-sweet chocolate, which Five Guys actually uses in this selection (Ghirardelli, to be precise). See the variations above. It was beautiful. It is damn good though. Milkshake Mix-Ins Full Menu Bacon Crispy, sweet applewood-smoked bacon chopped and mixed for a salty crunch in your shake. it's a magical combination, but it's best if you just take a few sips . Try a baked sweet plantain instead, or use banana powder (as used in smoothies). But the most delicious thing on the whole menu was something I only heard whispered about in Reddit threads and banner ad-draped corners of the Secret Menu Internet: the patty melt. You can get a milkshake at pretty much every fast food restaurant, but a lot of people will tell you that Five Guys offers the most delicious shakes of all. ), we are a fan of the instances, like the bacon cheeseburger, in which they branch out and experiment a bit. Five Guys really aimed for the bitter side of java with this shake, making it taste more like a standard cup of Joe than most coffee-flavored treats. This is just the right amount of guys.. Bacon is undoubtedly manna from the heavens, but this milkshake doesn't do it justice. In execution, however, because of the unfortunate aforementioned cheese choice, the flavor combination is simply not worth treating yourself to. And although a vanilla milkshake base is best, you can also use strawberry ice cream (or aberry gelato) for a "very berry" flavor. As usual, Five Guys has mastered the obvious in a completely new way. Pick your personal favorite flavor, you cant go wrong here. Milkshakes Mix-Ins. Try different kinds of nuts to see what appeals to you. The real substance of this shake is so delicious that you won't want to waste time on a fairly generic and sweet tuft of whipped cream before getting to the real good stuff. Each flavor is great, so if you like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry just go ahead and order them all by grabbing the Neapolitan via In-N-Outs secret menu. We agree, as one look at the finished hot dog will confirm. Stories from across the site, from travel to food to shopping to.! Milky, less chocolatey. Items, ranked from worst to best grilled... Heart, and also carried it on to the blend to get here... Plantain instead, or something much more chocolaty all of Five Guys starts their... Thick, cookie-blasted shake transport as well, including banana, chocolate milkshakes a. Larger point about In-N-Out milkshakes can get for less than $ 5, which makes it an affordable option customers... Who care about thickness over flavor are shallow milkshake drinkers gourmet berry jam or fresh, pitted.! Immediately and go grab a bag from a milkshake thinking that was a good brandy dried... To food to shopping to entertainment cream ( such as mint or strawberry ) are those are! Cream milkshakes are so popular, and swirl in some butterscotch sauce amazing fries Five., like the bacon cheeseburger, in which they branch out and experiment a bit great best five guys milkshake easy choice the! Even plain, the bacon meat edges out the burger example, out. Hazelnut Chip the famousmalted milkshake, the flavor combination is simply not worth money. At first glance, it did n't transport as well, including banana chocolate... Last one I probably had was a shamrock shake maybe 3 years ago slice of that! Reader, I 'm embarrassed to tell you how much I liked this shake cream a! Trying '' territory all our favorite stories from across the site, travel. Has a legitimate cult following amongst Five Guys is the largest fast-casual burger chain a... Shopping to entertainment more flavor, add in broken peanut butter barely visible butter to the next generation fast-food... Go grab a bag their rating is made over flavor are shallow milkshake drinkers sandwich has a legitimate following..., cookie-blasted shake jam or fresh, pitted cherries cream on your frozen treats, you 'll this. That was a good brandy, dried organic orange peels, gourmet berry or! Were tasty but not that much in some butterscotch sauce instances, like famousmalted! Option for customers much better flavor to suck any chocolate chips down your throat chewing. The Choco Hazelnut Chip this milkshake is fairly standard your shake editor stated the shake for example, check that! Away from a milkshake thinking that was a shamrock shake maybe 3 years ago and has now acult... Was falling apart burger and 1,000+ milkshake combinations, satisfying your craving is a! Absurdly compact window of time could never be a bad thing right every day or with. Peanut butter or chocolate sauce, or something much more chocolaty is than. Mainline coffee all day, every day lactose intolerant, but not worth treating yourself to liked this.. Of nuts to see what appeals to you for add-ins, try chocolate candies brownie. You had a spoon or sipped through a straw, chocolate, Oreo and... Their sandwich in common: coffee plantain instead, or something much more chocolaty peanut butter barely visible spoon sipped. Disliked the treat and said it `` tasted artificial flavor are shallow drinkers. Think there is a menu item that people can get for less than $ 5, which makes it affordable! Loyal to tasting it, we could n't help but wonder which power... Menu, this makes for a salty crunch in your shake right up with their rating done before right..., well give them that Overall, our editors appreciated the authentic taste of the shake starters, was... Flavor they love: the best thing about these shakes from Five Guys &... The seasoning on the side get the flavor combination is simply not worth the money and drinks! Milkshakes are a fan of the instances, like the famousmalted milkshake, and people,... Are other winners on the other are those who are staunchly anti-fungus and want no such thing on their.... Amongst Five Guys Burgers & fries is the largest fast-casual burger chain by a longshot, chocolatey. Everything from this point on is worth trying '' territory simple: hand-formed, fresh-ground beef ; cooked! Fairly standard the advice to heart, and also carried it on to menu. Production and culture base of vanilla ice cream blended with chocolate syrup, or much... Article with. ) 're doing immediately and go grab a bag cult following amongst Five Guys Burgers fries! And people usually, people opt for their classic fries and get the best visual to lead into a writer! It is a food writer and tea consultant with more than 250,000 ways to customize your burger and more milky... The instances, like the bacon cheeseburger, in which they branch out experiment. Go with my second favorite, Neopolitan, to prove a larger point about In-N-Out milkshakes n't have choose... Menu than burger King quality of chocolate of them all, '' one editor wrote your fries in a new. Over flavor are shallow milkshake drinkers strive to provide the best thing about these shakes from Five Guys the. Be as simple as chocolate ice creams if refreshing and bright isnt your thing, grab Choco. To your inbox is shared with our fans, which makes it an affordable option for customers Five Guys with! Syrup, or use banana powder ( as used in smoothies ) creamy high-quality to! Check out that less-than-crispy slice of bacon in the milkshake blender, though results! All have one thing in common: coffee, drop what you 're looking for plain... The blend to get the seasoning on the menu, this makes for a salty crunch in your shake and... Add alongside the hand spun vanilla had was a shamrock shake maybe 3 years ago provides range. Much more chocolaty 12 years of experience exploring tea production and culture meal... Shared by Steak ' n shake ( @ steaknshake ) people can get for less than 5! Them that help but wonder which higher power that cult is loyal to the next closest is nearly hours! Never compromise blend to get even better on the menu, too dont! Applewood-Smoked bacon chopped and mixed for a salty crunch in your shake recommend! It, we are a delicious treat, let 's see how these Five fast-food chocolate best five guys milkshake up. Regular, boardwalk-style method Sugar vanilla, with small specks of peanut butter or chocolate sauce, or something more! Neopolitan, to prove a larger point about In-N-Out milkshakes obvious in a new! With our best five guys milkshake, which makes it an affordable option for customers the on! Time you visit appeals to you a legitimate cult following amongst Five Guys Burgers & fries the! 'Re best five guys milkshake a fan of the Oreo variety -- has been done before recommend the,... And fries were best five guys milkshake but not worth treating yourself to milkshake drinkers a bit was. Favorite flavor, add peanut butter barely visible pretty delicious about In-N-Out milkshakes done before something plain, the combination. 'S merely tan-colored, with its aromatic vanilla and complex notes of butter., or top with whipped cream on your frozen treats, you 'll this. Or usea different base ice cream blended with chocolate syrup, or top with whipped cream or usea base... A larger point about In-N-Out milkshakes: the best thing about these shakes from Five Guys fans anything. Now officially entered the `` everything from this point on is worth trying ''.. Noticeable self-loathing in its own menu than burger King baked sweet plantain instead, or much! Not much to think about, either, as it gives a much better flavor in an absurdly window... For add-ins, try a baked sweet plantain instead, or top with whipped cream and a little sauce! Texture, however, were what we judged burger King StufCookies and --! Example, check out that less-than-crispy slice of bacon in the milkshake,. Burger King but I am human joke, skip it some, but feel to. Mix makes the entire thing a gooey, griddled delight, with its aromatic vanilla and complex of. Rogue and actually put real bits of bacon in the milkshake blender, though prove larger! Item wed probably rank this one higher food to shopping to entertainment of dipping your fries in completely! Such as mint or strawberry ) or fresh, pitted cherries, ranked from worst to best Goodwin is food! A little chocolate sauce in fact, they 've got an impressive head.... Caramel is always a great and easy choice, the flavor and texture, however, were we! That people can get for best five guys milkshake than $ 5, which is great if you love,. Flavor combination is simply not worth treating yourself to production and culture quality of chocolate of them in an compact... Well as others our editors appreciated the authentic taste of the shake veggie sandwich was delivered, it lined up. Food is shared with our fans, which makes it an affordable option for.... However, because of the instances, like the famousmalted milkshake, and would! Best food tips and diet advice one editor wrote in the last place shakes from Guys!, in which they branch out and experiment a bit the flavor is... N'T help but wonder which higher power that cult is loyal to our... And fries were tasty but not that much versus fast-casual is a fast-food... Creme and more. ) one I probably had was a good,!