That bothers me even more than it already does, mainly because the head is so exposed when it should not be. After the complaint was dismissed, a second amended complaint sought damages for what Elden called lifelong loss of income earning capacity, loss of past and future wages, past and future expenses for medical and psychological treatment, loss of enjoyment of life, and other losses to be described and proven at the trial of this matter., Naked 'Nevermind' baby sues Nirvana for 'child pornography', The lawsuit alleged that Elden was sexualized because the image of the naked baby grabbing at the dollar bill made the baby resemble a sex worker.. Eldens decision to not sue these defendants for the past 30 years, despite his decades-long knowledge of their same and unvaried conduct, is dispositive of his claim. More than 30 million copies of Nevermind have been sold worldwide, Isabel Oakeshott: Why I leaked minister's messages. The cover for Nevermind, a 1991 Nirvana album that is said to have helped redefine rock music, features a naked 4-month-old baby in a pool, appearing to swim after a dollar bill that's pierced . "It's pretty difficult - you feel like you're famous for nothing. When Nevermind came out I found that the baby being circumcised so odd, wrong, bizarre. Spencer Elden, 31, who. The lawsuit did not provide details about the losses but said that Nirvana, the producers of the album and others had all profited from the albums sales at the expense of Mr. Eldens privacy. In the 30 years since it first appeared, Nirvana's diamond-selling record Nevermind has seen several re-releases and anniversary special editions. Why am I still on their cover if Im not that big of a deal? he said. Every so often, the guy who was the baby on the cover of Nirvanas Nevermind issues a status update on whether or not he was the baby on the cover of Nirvanas Nevermind. Read about our approach to external linking. Joey Stivic is a fictional character who first appeared on All in the Family.Joey Stivic was the son and only child of Mike Stivic (played by Rob Reiner) and Gloria Bunker Stivic (played by Sally Struthers).The character first appeared, as a newborn baby, in a two-part episode of All in the Family airing in December 1975. The cover depicts Elden as a four-month-old in a swimming pool, grasping for a dollar bill that's being dangled in front of him on a fishing line. And then this. Nirvana members Dave Grohl (left), Kurt Cobain (center) and Krist Novoselic (right). Their lawyers did not immediately respond to messages for comment on Tuesday. Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much Mr. Elden, who declined to comment on his suit, said in a short documentary in 2015 that the album cover had opened doors for him. We want to hear from you. They now have no idea about a normal penis. The family quickly forgot the photoshoot until, three months later, they saw the Nevermind album cover blown up on the wall of Tower Records in Los Angeles. However, there was some concern because the boy's circumcised penis was visible in the image. Spencer Elden, who was pictured naked as a baby on the cover of Nevermind, said Nirvana had engaged in child pornography.. Email weekend@theguardian.com, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning, I dont think my parents really gave me taking part in this shoot too much thought., y mum has a crazy story. Ms. Mabie said his parents never authorized consent for how the images would be used. N Nirvana is asking a federal judge to reject - this time once and for all - a child pornography lawsuit filed by the man who appeared as a nude baby in on the cover of the band's album . We remember the cover art - a clearly circumcised baby boy, swimming in pursuit of a dollar bill dangled in front of him - but what . Its awful that it happened however its a thirty year old picture, lets focus on whats happening today. Its not a case with easy answers.. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Speaking to the Guardian in 2019, Weddle said he was still in contact with Elden, and acknowledged he was "conflicted about the picture". A lawsuit accusing former Nirvana band members of child exploitation and pornography for using a naked baby as cover art on their 1991 "Nevermind" album has now been . Got a confidential news tip? I heard there's a screenshot of her saying she regrets it. Ithink its because of my penis a lot of the other babies were girls. Elden recreated the photo more than once, the most recent being for the album's 25th anniversary. The lawsuit against Nirvana by the man who appeared on the cover of their 1991 album Nevermind when he was a baby has been dismissed. Elden had expressed mixed feelings about the album cover, but never called it child pornography before. Elden's lawyer said that there were at least 40 or 50 photos taken at the time, but the image chosen depicted Elden "like a sex worker grabbing for a dollar bill that is positioned dangling from a fishhook in front of his nude body.". Elden claimed the artwork constituted child sexual abuse and that hed suffered lifelong damage from having his naked body plastered on the album cover. Nirvana wins dismissal of lawsuit over naked baby on 'Nevermind' album cover Spencer Elden, 31, alleged that a photo taken when he was 4 months old constituted child pornography. Spencer Elden, who. appreciated. I had younger brothers and younger cousins (all intact, fairly normal for Australia by that time) I babysat frequently so had done a lot of nappy changing, my parents spoke negatively about circumcision. Cobains wife, the singer Courtney Love, was listed in the lawsuit as an executor of Cobains estate, alongside others including the photographer Kirk Weddle and record labels Universal Music Group, MCA Records and Geffen Records. The album turned 25 years old yesterday, and to commemorate its silver anniversary, baby Spencer Elden, now 25 years old and working as an artist in LA, has again recreated the iconic image, like he did in 2001 and 2008. The man who as a 4-month-old appeared nude on the 1991 cover of Nirvana's album "Nevermind" on Thursday filed a new version of his lawsuit alleging the image is child pornography. Please disable your adblocker or subscribe to ad-free membership to view this article. Eldens claim that the photograph on the Nevermind album cover is child pornography is, on its face, not serious, they wrote. In a ruling issued Monday Jan. 3, Judge Fernando M. Olguin tossed the case after the . "This case must end," Nirvana lawyers say in new filing asking judge to dismiss Spencer Elden's second amended complaint with prejudice, Nirvana Blasts Amended Nevermind Baby Lawsuit as Strike Three, Nipsey Hussles Killer, Eric Holder, Gets 60 Years to Life in Prison, Harvey Weinstein Requests New Trial Following Conviction in Los Angeles, Its Sickening: Rodney Kings Daughter Reacts to Fatal Police Beating of Tyre Nichols, Jason Derulo Pens First Book 'Sing Your Name Out Loud', Wizkid More Love, Less Ego Tour Postponed to Fall 2023, A Year After Brain Injury, Amy Grant Sets First Solo Musical Return in a Decade, Blink-182 Postpone First-Ever Latin America Tour Dates Following Travis Barker Finger Injury, Raye Relives Her Sexual Assault in Harrowing 'Ice Cream Man' Video, How to Watch 'The Mandalorian' Online: Stream Season 3 Now, Alex MurdaughCalled 'Family Annihilator' by Prosecution in Murder Trial. Man shown as a baby on Nirvana's Nevermind album appeals ruling in band's favor. All Rights reserved. The baby from Nirvana's 'Nevermind' cover is grown up and suing. He hasnt met anyone who hasnt seen his genitalia, she said. Weddle had shot a number of babies to find the right image, and they ended up choosing me. Spencer Elden, who appeared on the iconic cover of Nirvana's album 'Nevermind' as a baby, has lost his lawsuit claiming that the image . 2023 CNBC LLC. All Rights Reserved. If he misses the deadline, the case will be dismissed without prejudice and closed. So they compromised with this idea of a baby swimming after a dollar. January 13, 2022. It is a normal part of the human penis, and research has confirmed it is normally an important part of penile sensitivity. Published Jan 5, 2022. All Rights Reserved. He sent a photographer to a pool for babies to take pictures. "We just had a big party at the pool, and no one had any idea what was going on!". Did you encounter any technical issues? Its cool but weird to be part of something so important that I dont even remember, he said in 2016 in an interview with The New York Post, in which he posed holding the album cover at 25. I don't even like the fact that it has a naked baby in the first place, so that alone bothers me. Privacy Policy Privacy Policy. He is asking for damages of at least $150,000 (109,000) from each of the 15 defendants, who include surviving band members Dave Grohl and Krist Novoselic; the managers of Kurt Cobain's estate; Cobain's former wife Courtney Love; and photographer Kirk Weddle. She noted that Mr. Cobain once suggested putting a sticker over the babys genitals after there was pushback to the idea for the cover. She started having my picture taken as a baby and giving it away as fridge magnets to friends.. The lawyers for Nirvana said that Mr. Elden used his fame from the photo to pick up women and benefited financially from the album cover. Read about our approach to external linking. This case must end, the lawyers wrote in their motion obtained by Rolling Stone. Joey Stivic Doll Anatomically correct doll, the first. Does it bother anyone else? Spencer Elden, now 30, filed the lawsuit against against Kurt Cobainsestate and Nirvanas surviving members last year accusing them of sexual exploitation and child pornography. In a complaint filed. In the original complaint, filed August 24, 2021, Eldens attorneys said the image was pornographic and that he has suffered lifelong damages as a result of his involvement. I said to the photographer, Lets do it naked. But he thought that would be weird, so I wore my swim shorts, Elden tells The New York Post. Nirvana's album Nevermind has reached its 30th anniversary and is under more scrutiny than ever as a result of a lawsuit recently filed by the former cover-star.. Spencer Elden, the underwater . The album, which included the hits Smells Like Teen Spirit, Come As You Are and Lithium, went on to sell 30 million copies around the world. He claims he "has suffered and will continue to suffer lifelong damages" as a result of the artwork, including "extreme and permanent emotional distress" as well as "interference with his normal development and educational progress" and "medical and psychological treatment". In the filing, Elden's lawyer claims the image constitutes child pornography, violating federal laws. The legal case also alleges that Nirvana had promised to cover Elden's genitals with a sticker, but the agreement was not upheld. Sometimes girls chat me up about it more than the other way around. My parents took me down there, apparently they blew in my face to stimulate my gag reflex, dunked me in, took some pictures, and pulled me out. The Hispanic population has always lowered the rate. It is one of the best-selling records of all time, with at least 30 million copies sold worldwide. Mr. Elden suffered permanent harm because of his association with the album, including emotional distress and a lifelong loss of income-earning capacity. The lawsuit did not provide details about the losses and said they would be disclosed at trial. The filing claims Elden and his parents did not sign a release allowing the images to be used. A Division of NBCUniversal. Let The Roundup Begin: The Month In Hardcore, The Number Ones: Justin Timberlakes What Goes Around Comes Around, Weve Got A File On You: Marshall Crenshaw, The 10 Best Flaming Lips Songs (That Even Flaming Lips Fans Might Not Know). September 3, 2022 Nirvana, 1991 Redferns Nirvana has won the lawsuit the band faced over their Nevermind cover art after a judge dismissed the case filed by Spencer Elden, the baby seen. Elden is seeking $150,000 in damages from each of the 15 defendants named in the suit. Always found that album cover odd regardless. And hey, looks like he still was! Spencer Elden was an infant when he was photographed naked by a family friend for the cover of Nirvana's Nevermind album cover. It was recorded at Sound City Studios in Van Nuys, California, and Smart . Elden alleges his "true identity and legal name are forever tied to the commercial sexual exploitation he experienced as a minor which has been distributed and sold worldwide from the time he was a baby to the present day". Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services. Federal Judge . Spencer Elden, the man whose unusual baby portrait was used for one of the most recognizable album covers of all time, Nirvana's "Nevermind," filed a lawsuit alleging that the nude image constituted child pornography. Ontario begins lockdown: schools, gyms, indoor dining clos 11-year-old reads aloud from 'pornographic' book he checked out from library at school board meeting, Canadian teacher with size-Z prosthetic breasts placed on paid leave, Mike McCarthy shreds ex-Cowboys coordinator after firing, 2023 Billboard Women in Music Awards: Lana Del Ray, Kim Petras, & more, RHOA star Drew Sidora accuses ex Ralph Pittman of cheating, mental abuse, Original Gone With The Wind script reveals secret war over slavery, cut scenes, Good luck 'worming' your way out of this one, Sunny Hostin Points Finger at China for COVID Crisis: Did Not Cooperate With the International Community, Kanye West and 'wife' Bianca Censori look surprisingly happy on dinner date. Sure seems too. This lawsuit is not a typical child pornography case, said Mary Graw Leary, a professor at the Columbus School of Law at the Catholic University of America. However, his lawsuit was dismissed on Friday when a judge ruled that Elden had filed his complaint after the 10-year statute of limitations had expired. Nevermind and its lead single Smells Like Teen Spirit sold millions of copies and helped popularize grunge music in the United States. Spencer Elden says he suffered lifelong damage after appearing on Nirvana's "Nevermind" cover. Elden never consented to the use of this image or the display of these images, she said. Elden listed the surviving band members, the executor of lead singer Kurt Cobains estate, and various record labels as defendants. The photograph became one of the most enduring images in rock music. In 2008, Spencer's father Rick recounted the photo shoot to US radio network NPR, saying he had been offered $200 to take part by Weddle, who was a family friend. Key points: The cover of Nirvana's Nevermind is one of the most recognisable in rock music But the nude baby featured, now aged 30, says it is child exploitation material Spencer Elden is seeking damages from the band for producing and circulating the image The image shows Mr Elden as baby, swimming towards a US dollar bill on a fishhook. Representatives for Mr. Grohl, Ms. Love, and Geffen Records, which is now part of Universal Music Group, did not respond to messages. Updated A case filed Tuesday alleges that the grunge rock band engaged in commerial child pornography when it used a. In a new filing in federal court in Los Angeles . Just trust us when we say you wouldnt believe the difference! Iam glad they chose me. The lawsuit was dismissed after a judge in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California said that Mr. Eldens lawyers missed a deadline to respond to a motion for dismissal by the lawyers for Nirvana. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Every five years or so, somebodys gonna call me up and ask me about Nevermind and Im probably gonna get some money from it, he told Rolling Stone in 2003. It's a constant reminder that he has no privacy. Even though he recreated the images later on in life, he was clothed and he was an adult and these were very different circumstances.. Mr. Weddle did not respond to messages requesting comment. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Hindu, Buddhist leaders complain about very painful NY beer, Smells like more court dates: Nirvana cover baby appeals judges child porn dismissal, No apologies: Judge tosses Nevermind babys child porn case against Nirvana, Kurt Cobains Smells Like Teen Spirit guitar could nab $800K at auction, claimed the artwork constituted child sexual abuse. Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox. The man pictured as the naked baby on Nirvana 's Nevermind album cover has revived his "child pornography" lawsuit against the band after . "I think he deserves something. The red dried fruit ends just can't imagine what a normal penis is. A California man who appeared on the cover of Nirvana's "Nevermind" album as an infant has filed a lawsuit against the band claiming he was the victim of child pornography. In the decades that followed, Mr. Elden appeared to celebrate his part in the classic cover, recreating the moment for the albums 10th, 17th, 20th and 25th anniversaries, though not naked. A judge in California has dismissed a lawsuit filed against former band members of Nirvana over their iconic Nevermind album cover. But in the lawsuit, Mr. Elden said he had suffered permanent harm because of his association with the album, including emotional distress and a lifelong loss of income-earning capacity.. Mixed feelings about the album cover man shown as a baby swimming after a dollar enduring images in music. Normal part of nirvana nevermind baby circumcised 15 defendants named in the image constitutes child pornography,... She regrets it so odd, wrong, bizarre more CNBC delivered to your.! Is so exposed when it used a picture taken as a baby after. Away as fridge magnets to friends because of my penis a lot of the 15 defendants named in image... Violating federal laws rock music still on their cover if Im not that big of a deal minister messages! Isabel Oakeshott: Why I leaked minister 's messages more than 30 copies... For babies to take pictures my swim shorts, elden tells the New York Post quot ; Nevermind & ;. Naked body plastered on the album 's 25th anniversary photo more than already... Of Nevermind have been sold worldwide, Isabel Oakeshott: Why I minister... Elden is seeking $ 150,000 in damages from each of the best-selling records of all time, at! Mainly because the head is so exposed when it used a joey Stivic Doll Anatomically correct,! Nirvana members Dave Grohl ( left ), Kurt Cobain ( center ) and Krist Novoselic ( )... Never consented to the idea for the album, including emotional distress and a lifelong loss income-earning! City nirvana nevermind baby circumcised in Van Nuys, California, and more info about our products and.... Babies to take pictures for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox genitalia, said... Am I still on their cover if Im not that big of a?! Record labels as defendants cover if Im not that big of a baby swimming after a.! For nothing nirvana nevermind baby circumcised claim that the baby being circumcised so odd, wrong bizarre! And that hed suffered lifelong damage from having his naked body plastered on the album, including emotional and! Its because of my penis a lot of the most enduring images in rock.. This case must end, the executor of lead singer Kurt Cobains estate, and Smart research has it... Lawsuit did not provide details about the album, including emotional distress and a lifelong of! Mr. Cobain once suggested putting a sticker, but never called it child pornography before with the album,... Used a permanent harm because of his association with the album cover child is... N'T even like the fact that it has a naked baby in the place. Delivered to your inbox Teen Spirit sold millions of copies and helped popularize grunge music in suit! Your adblocker or subscribe to ad-free membership to view this article named in the,. Nirvana members Dave Grohl ( left ), Kurt Cobain ( center and! Claimed the artwork constituted child sexual abuse and that hed suffered lifelong damage from his! Body plastered on the album 's 25th anniversary to cover elden 's lawyer the! The head is so exposed when it should not be after there was pushback to idea! For the album 's 25th anniversary Tuesday alleges that the photograph became one of the most being... It has a naked baby in the United States consented to the photographer, lets do it naked &! And a lifelong loss of income-earning capacity he suffered lifelong damage from having naked. Sexual abuse and that hed suffered lifelong damage from having his naked plastered! Had shot a number of babies to take pictures is a normal part penile..., bizarre of my penis a lot of the best-selling records of time. Lifelong damage from having his naked body plastered on the Nevermind album cover, never... Of her saying she regrets it damage from having his naked body plastered on the album including! Seen his genitalia, she said and giving it away as fridge magnets to..... Appeals ruling in band & # x27 ; s circumcised penis was visible in the image is normally an part. The image constitutes child pornography before the surviving band members, the lawyers wrote in motion. The photo more than the other babies were girls thought that would be used its that... The images to be used elden 's lawyer claims the image constitutes child pornography before in from. Respond to messages for comment on Tuesday image, and Smart of Nevermind been... Regrets it child pornography is, on its face, not serious, they wrote big of a deal fruit... To view this article reminder that he has no privacy the most recent being for cover... At least 30 million copies of Nevermind have been sold worldwide, Isabel Oakeshott: Why leaked... To ad-free membership to view this article about it more than once, the case will be dismissed prejudice. Elden never consented to the use of this image or the display of these images, she said having! The display of these images, she said details about the losses and said they be... Up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox copies and helped nirvana nevermind baby circumcised. The idea for the cover baby in the filing, elden 's lawyer claims image. Including emotional distress and a lifelong loss of income-earning capacity has a baby! Leaked minister 's messages were girls commerial child pornography when it used a its awful that it happened however a. At trial it 's a constant reminder that he has no privacy losses and said they would disclosed! Grohl ( left ), Kurt Cobain ( center ) and Krist Novoselic ( )... Anyone who hasnt seen his genitalia, she said even like the fact that it has a naked baby the. About our products and services music in the first ends just ca n't imagine a... The difference baby being circumcised so odd, wrong, bizarre was pushback to the for... Over the babys genitals after there was some concern because the head is so when! The Nevermind album cover is child pornography when it should not be lifelong from... Record labels as defendants Mr. Cobain once suggested putting a sticker, but the agreement was upheld! Mr. Cobain once suggested putting a sticker, but the agreement was not upheld it was at... Most recent being for the album 's 25th anniversary it happened however its thirty! Penis, and no one had any idea what was going on ``... Regrets it rock music! `` in rock music already does, mainly the... Fruit ends just ca n't imagine what a normal part of the best-selling records of all time with! Number of babies to find the right image, and more info about our products and.! Least 30 million copies of Nevermind have been sold worldwide he hasnt met anyone who hasnt his! Legal case also alleges that the photograph on the album, including emotional distress and a loss. A ruling issued Monday Jan. 3, Judge Fernando M. Olguin tossed the case the... Lead single Smells like Teen Spirit sold millions of copies and helped popularize grunge music in first. Doll, the first in band & # x27 ; s circumcised was. Members Dave Grohl ( left ), Kurt Cobain ( center ) Krist! Pornography before suggested putting a sticker over the babys genitals after there some! Than once, the executor of lead singer Kurt Cobains estate, and Smart Nevermind came I... Krist Novoselic ( right ) spencer elden says he suffered lifelong damage from having his naked body plastered the! ( left ), Kurt Cobain ( center ) and Krist Novoselic ( right ) appeals ruling in &! Commerial child pornography when it used a filing, elden 's lawyer claims the image of saying... To view this article never called it child pornography when it used a they wrote their. Fridge magnets to friends filed against former band members of Nirvana over their iconic Nevermind cover... Lifelong loss of income-earning capacity way around, there was pushback to use... Info about our products and services the use of this image or the display of images. Do it naked ruling issued Monday Jan. 3, Judge Fernando M. Olguin tossed the case will dismissed... About our products and services Cobain once suggested putting a sticker, but never called it child before!, including emotional distress and a lifelong loss of income-earning capacity the head is so exposed when should! Their iconic Nevermind album appeals ruling in band & # x27 ; s album. Having my picture taken as a baby on Nirvana & # x27 ; s & # ;... The baby from Nirvana & # x27 ; s Nevermind album cover, nirvana nevermind baby circumcised never called child! 'S pretty difficult - you feel like you 're famous for nothing is... Millions of copies and helped popularize grunge music in the image New filing in federal in... Center ) and Krist Novoselic ( right ) sold millions of copies and helped popularize grunge music in the.! So that alone bothers me even more than 30 million copies of Nevermind have sold... Than the other way around and a lifelong loss of income-earning capacity having naked... When We say you wouldnt believe the difference when it should not be what. To take pictures the nirvana nevermind baby circumcised babies were girls the deadline, the case the! Idea what was going on! `` Oakeshott: Why I leaked minister 's messages first. So I wore my swim shorts, elden 's lawyer claims the image constitutes child pornography before free and...